Sessions at SXSW Interactive 2011 of type Panel about Ethics

View as grid

Your current filters are…


Sunday 13th March 2011

  • Crowdsourcing: Innovation and/or Exploitation?

    by Fred Benenson, Jonathan Zittrain, Lada Adamic and Lukas Biewald

    You've probably already heard about crowdsourcing platforms like Amazon’s Mechanical Turk and CrowdFlower which offer anyone the ability to employ thousands of humans to perform on demand micro-assignments at pennies per task.

    But does crowdsourcing even work? What value can thousands of dislocated clicks really provide? Is this really the future of online labor?

    In this panel we’ll be examining the topic of crowdsourcing, the crowdsourced labor market, and the entrepreneurial and creative opportunities made possible by “human APIs.”

    We’ll also tackle some of the newest innovations in crowdsourcing such as virtual labor for virtual goods where Farmville and other MMPOG gamers are awarded in-game currency for doing real-world microwork such as tagging photos and filling out surveys.

    However there's growing concern that these Farmville migrant workers are being unfairly exploited. This is further complicated by the fact that many of them happen to be minors.

    But does it even make sense to equivocate their work with “normal” labor? Are there really people living in developing nations that live hand-to-mouth on their income from crowdsourcing? Finally, what are the regulatory and social considerations that we can expect in the future for this space?

    LEVEL: Intermediate

    At 5:00pm to 6:00pm, Sunday 13th March

    In Room 9ABC, Austin Convention Center

Monday 14th March 2011

  • Bite Me—Are Ethics Gone in Food Criticism?

    by Marcia Gagliardi, Robert Sietsema, Jane Goldman, Ben Leventhal and James Holmes

    In the past, food critics paid for their meals and were reimbursed by the newspaper/magazine. And most mainstream media food critics would go to exceptional ends to keep their identity secret. Their critique of the food would be unmarred by any special treatment from the restaurant chef or staff. End of story. But today everyone's a food critic, and with the rise in social media sites like Twitter, Facebook, Foursquare, and more, their reviews can be broadcast far and wide. Food critic anonymity has gone out the window with one Google search.
    Recently, Time.com food critic, Josh Ozersky was dressed down by the Village Voice* NYT for not revealing in a column in which he extolled the benefits of having fancy chefs catering your wedding that the caterers at his wedding were doing so for free. The recent FTC rulings mandate that bloggers disclose when they're reviewing something they're not paid for, but those rules don't extend to bloggers operating under the leaky umbrella of a corporate parent.
    In the proposed panel, Jane Goldman, editor in chief of CHOW.com, one of the most popular food websites, will bring some of the most influential people in the food industry and discuss this growingly important issue in food journalism. This panel will call out the spectrum of professionalism in online and offline food journalism and the issue around transparency reverberates through all aspects of online journalism and blogging.

    LEVEL: Intermediate

    At 11:00am to 12:00pm, Monday 14th March

    In Hill Country AB, Hyatt Regency Austin