Tutorial: Collaborative Critique – A New Usability Evaluation Method for Assessing Human-Computer Collaboration.

A session at UXPA 2013

  • Dr. Wendy Lucas

In this tutorial, we will introduce a new usability walkthrough method called the Collaborative Critique (CC) that is inspired by the human-computer collaboration paradigm of system-user interaction. This walkthrough method is motivated by the need for a usability inspection technique that focuses on the usefulness of the system and is applicable to complex information systems as well as smaller-scale consumer websites and applications.

The tutorial will include a detailed description of the CC method as well as its theoretical foundations and results from a practical evaluation. We will highlight how the CC method differs from existing inspection methods and mitigates some of their problems by taking a “system-as-a-user’s collaborative partner” approach, which evaluates how strongly the system’s behavior fits the characteristics of a helpful and intelligent co-worker. The principles behind the method and examples of their application to user interfaces will help the participants in not only performing the CC walkthrough but also in guiding the design of interfaces.

A hands-on exercise in applying the Collaborative Critique will also be included in the tutorial. We hope to follow up the tutorial with an on-line discussion between the participants and authors of the CC method concerning their experiences with using the method.

About the speakers

This person is speaking at this event.
Dr. Tamara Babaian

Assoc. Professor, Computer Information Systems Department, Bentley University

Tamara Babaian is an Associate Professor of Computer Information Systems at Bentley University. She received her PhD from Tufts University, followed by a Post-Doctorate fellowship at Harvard University. Tamara’s research in intelligent and collaborative systems has been focusing on (1) the design and evaluation of collaborative system-user interactions and (2) algorithms and representations that support human-computer collaboration. Her HCI work has appeared in proceedings of ACM CHI, Intelligent User Interfaces conference, International Conference on Enterprise Information Systems and other conference and journal publications.

This person is speaking at this event.
Dr. Wendy Lucas

Professor, Computer Information Systems Department, Bentley University

Wendy Lucas is a Professor of Computer Information Systems at Bentley University. She received her PhD from the Electrical Engineering and Computer Science Department at Tufts University and an MS from the MIT Sloan School of Management. Her research focuses on human-computer collaboration and information visualization, with publications in proceedings of ACM CHI, IEEE Symposium on Visual Languages, and ACM Multimedia. Her industry experience includes founding a medical software company and serving as a marketing and technology consultant to small businesses.

Sign in to add slides, notes or videos to this session

Tell your friends!


Date Tue 9th July 2013

Short URL


Official session page


View the schedule


See something wrong?

Report an issue with this session