Heretics, High Priests, and Hagiolatry

A session at Lean Agile Scotland 2015

Wednesday 7th October, 2015

10:20am to 10:50am (GMT)

It could be argued that tribes, communities of practice, organizations, and societies accrete symbolic systems that forge a common language over time to accomplish tasks usually related to the preservation, extension of power, and access to resources needed to continue to flourish and allow these networks within boundaries to feel a sense of agency and empowerment. Indeed, when one group or tribe within a larger ecosystem feels threatened or produces radical new ideas, the heretical rebels leverage common metaphors, symbols, and tactics to achieve strategic goals – at first rebelling against the existing power structure (writing manifestos, throwing molotov cocktail), supplanting the existing “high priests”. Eventually, though, they develop the same rituals that previous power structure utilized to maintain and extend their power base – the heretics eventually become the high priests of a new caste system and then anoint their own saints.

We have seen this evolution in social systems and the accretion of ‘webs of signification’ in the context of IT in general and software design and development in particular. The anthropologist Clifford Geertz said that “man is an animal suspended in webs of significance he himself has spun, I take culture to be those webs,” which can inform our understanding of tribes in a software enterprise setting. With each new principled-based movement within IT, from RUP to Agile, to Lean Software, to Lean UX and more recently DevOps and Lean Startup, the new tribe has the need to extend it’s power base beyond the context for which it was originally intended. Even if each tribe armed with their own methods and practices makes sense at a given time and place, this does not necessarily mean it’s appropriate or strategic from a systems, wholistic, enterprise, or societal perspective.

This notion is important in making strategic decisions from an enterprise perspective in terms of which ideology to deploy, how to allocate resources, and how to ensure that across the portfolio of potential ‘bets’ the appropriate methods are deployed. This tension – between tribes that wish to enjoy greater agency by proselytizing their ideology and methods into other domains, and the needs of the organization, which seeks balance across multiple competing factions to actually achieve enterprise-wide goals, is the primary challenge faced by leaders.

We’ll explore these notions, and seek to understand the various roles (scout, pioneer, settler, town planners), practices, and methods that are either local-optima or more global in perspective, to seek to provide a framework for decision-making in uncertain and turbulent times. We’ll unpack the relationship between different horizons from probable to possible, and provide some heuristics for when things like Design Thinking or LeanUX are most appropriate, and when Agile, PMBOK, or ITIL frameworks might be the most authentic satisficing lens through which to make decisions.

About the speaker

This person is speaking at this event.
Will Evans

Design Thinker-in-Residence @NYUStern, CxO advisor on Lean, Design & Systems Thinking, Founder of LeanUXNYC, Upper West Side, #CoffeeUp, Le Système c’est moi! bio from Twitter

Will was previously the Managing Director of TLCLabs, the world’s leading Lean Design Innovation consultancy where he has brought Lean Startup, LeanUX, and Design Thinking to large media, finance, and healthcare companies.

Before TLC, he led experience design and research for TheLadders in New York City. He has over 15 years industry experience in design innovation, user experience strategy and research. His roles include directing UX for social network analytics & terrorism modeling at AIR Worldwide, UX Architect for social media site Gather.com, and UX Architect for travel search engine Kayak.com. He worked at Lotus/IBM where he was the senior information architect, and for Curl – a DARPA-funded MIT project when he was at the MIT Laboratory for Computer Science.

He lives in New York, NY, and drinks far too much coffee. He Co-Founded and Co-Chaired the LeanUX NYC conference, and is the User Experience track chair for the Agile 2013 and Agile 2014 conferences.

Previous #LASCOT talks include:
Exploration & Exploitation Mindsets in Design-Driven Enterprises – 2014
LeanUX is a Useful F&*king Lie

Next session in Pentland East

11:20am Do more shit together: social networks at work by Marc Burgauer

7 attendees

  • Hans Kohls
  • Alejandro Alonso
  • Colin McCormick
  • Dominic Smith
  • Jon Hopkins
  • Kevin Murray
  • Will Evans

Sign in to add slides, notes or videos to this session

Sign in to track this session

Tell your friends!


Time 10:20am10:50am GMT

Date Wed 7th October 2015

Short URL


Official event site


View the schedule


See something wrong?

Report an issue with this session